The stock-to-flow (SF) model is a concept used to analyze and value cryptocurrencies, particularly Bitcoin. It was introduced by PlanB, a Dutch analyst and Bitcoin advocate. The model compares the existing supply of an asset (stock) to the amount of new supply that is added each year (flow).
The SF model is based on the idea that the scarcity of an asset, as measured by its SF ratio, is a key driver of its value. According to the model, as the SF ratio increases, the value of the asset should also increase. This is because a higher SF ratio means that the asset is becoming more scarce, which should make it more valuable to investors.
To calculate the SF ratio, you divide the existing supply (or "stock") of an asset by the amount of new supply (or "flow") that is added each year. For example, let's calculate the SF ratio for Bitcoin. As of January 2021, the total supply of Bitcoin is approximately 18.7 million coins. Each year, about 328,500 new coins are added to the supply through the process of mining. This means that the SF ratio for Bitcoin is:
SF ratio = Stock / Flow SF ratio = 18,700,000 / 328,500 SF ratio ≈ 57
According to the SF model, the SF ratio for Bitcoin is expected to continue increasing as the number of new coins added each year decreases and the total supply approaches its maximum limit of 21 million coins. This should drive up the value of Bitcoin, making it a desirable investment for those looking to hedge against inflation and other economic uncertainty.
Here is a hand-drawn plot illustrating the SF ratio for Bitcoin over time:
|
| .
| .
| .
|_______________________________________________> Time
SF Ratio
As you can see, the SF ratio for Bitcoin increases over time as the number of new coins added each year decreases. This is an important factor to consider when evaluating the potential value of Bitcoin as an investment.
In the world of Bitcoin, scarcity and value are deeply intertwined. Bitcoin has a maximum supply of 21 million coins, and as of today, over 18.7 million bitcoins have been mined. This inherent scarcity is one of the main reasons why Bitcoin has value.
To understand this better, let's break it down with an example from the video. Imagine you are in a class of 100 students, and the professor announces that there are only 100 pizzas available for the whole year, with each student only allowed to have one pizza per month. This created scarcity would make those pizzas highly valuable to the students.
Now, let's look at it from a computational perspective. The process of creating new bitcoins is called 'mining,' where miners compete to solve complex mathematical problems. As more bitcoins are mined, the problems become increasingly difficult, which requires more computational power and energy. This mechanism is built into Bitcoin's code, ensuring that the creation of new bitcoins slows down over time, further emphasizing its scarcity.
When it comes to real-world examples, the video highlights the story of Laszlo Hanyecz, who infamously spent 10,000 bitcoins on two Papa John's pizzas in 2010. At the time, it seemed like an overpayment, but given that 10,000 bitcoins are now worth millions of dollars, it turned out to be a historically significant transaction that showcases Bitcoin's value and potential.
In the video, they also share a code snippet of Bitcoin's source code, which illustrates the maximum supply cap:
static const int64 MAX_MONEY = 21000000 * COIN;
This line of code highlights the 21 million coin limit, emphasizing the scarcity that contributes to Bitcoin's value.
The Stock-to-Flow (S2F) model, popularized by Twitter user PlanB, claims to provide a robust framework for predicting Bitcoin's price by examining its scarcity. However, several limitations to this model are worth considering.
First, the S2F model is based on the assumption that an asset's scarcity is the primary driver of its value. While scarcity is certainly an important factor, it is not the only factor that determines an asset's price. Other factors, such as market demand, investor sentiment, and technological developments, also play a significant role in determining the price of Bitcoin.
As we can see, the S2F ratio of gold has increased steadily over the past century. However, the price of gold has not followed this trend in a linear fashion. Instead, the price of gold has been subject to significant fluctuations, driven by market demand, investor sentiment, and other external factors.
Another limitation of the S2F model is that it assumes that Bitcoin's production rate follows a predictable and steady curve. However, this is not necessarily the case. In reality, the production rate of Bitcoin can be affected by various factors, such as changes to the mining difficulty or regulatory developments.
As we can see, the actual production rate of Bitcoin has deviated significantly from the projected production rate in the past. This suggests that the S2F model may not be able to accurately predict the production rate of Bitcoin in the future.
Additionally, the S2F model assumes that the price of Bitcoin will continue to follow a logarithmic growth curve indefinitely. However, this is not a given. In reality, the price of Bitcoin may be subject to significant fluctuations, as we have seen in the past.
As we can see, the price of Bitcoin has experienced significant fluctuations over time, with some periods of strong growth followed by significant corrections. This suggests that the price of Bitcoin may not follow a smooth logarithmic growth curve as predicted by the S2F model.
Utility is the usefulness of a product or service, and in the case of Bitcoin, it's digital gold. People value Bitcoin for its scarcity and decentralized nature, but its utility is what drives its value.
Let's take a step-by-step calculation to understand this better.
Say you're a merchant and you've just sold a product for 1 BTC. The utility of Bitcoin, in this case, is its ability to allow you to conduct business without relying on traditional financial institutions, saving you transaction fees. This means that the value of Bitcoin to you is not just its market price, but also the money you save through its utility.
Now, let's examine a quote from Andreas Antonopoulos, a well-known Bitcoin advocate:
"Bitcoin's utility is derived from its decentralized, trustless nature. It is not bound by traditional financial systems, and thus provides people around the world with a means of transferring value without the need for intermediaries."
This anecdote highlights Bitcoin's utility in providing financial services to people in parts of the world where traditional financial systems have failed. For these individuals, Bitcoin's utility is its ability to provide a reliable store of value and means of transferring funds, which ultimately drives its value.
Hand-drawn plot time! Imagine a graph with two lines: one representing Bitcoin's utility and the other its market price. As the utility of Bitcoin increases, so does its market price. This is because people are willing to pay more for something that is useful and valuable to them.
The Stock-to-Flow (S2F) model is a popular framework used to price Bitcoin, based on the idea that the scarcity of an asset drives its value. The model measures the stock of an asset (total supply) against the flow (annual production) to predict its price. However, there are several criticisms of the model that have been raised in recent years.
One major criticism is that the S2F model is too simple and fails to account for various factors that can affect Bitcoin's price. For example, the S2F model assumes a linear relationship between scarcity and value, which may not always be the case. In the real world, other factors such as market sentiment, adoption rate, and regulatory environment can impact Bitcoin's price.
Another criticism is that the S2F model is based on historical data, which may not always be predictive of future trends. For instance, the S2F model fails to account for the impact of halving events, where the block reward is cut in half, on Bitcoin's price. While halving events do increase Bitcoin's scarcity, their impact on price is not always predictable. For example, during the 2020 halving, Bitcoin's price initially dropped, contradicting the S2F model's prediction.
Moreover, some critics argue that the S2F model creates a self-fulfilling prophecy, where the model's predictions become a self-fulfilling prophecy due to the widespread acceptance of the model in the Bitcoin community. This can lead to price manipulation and herding behavior, as investors buy into Bitcoin in anticipation of its predicted price.
Anecdotally, one famous example of this was the infamous "Bitcoin will reach $1 million by 2025" prediction by PlanB, a popular Bitcoin analyst, who used the S2F model to make this prediction. While the prediction did not come true, it did cause a significant increase in Bitcoin's price due to the market's belief in the S2F model and the accompanying hype.
Additionally, some critics point out that the S2F model fails to take into account the potential impact of disruptive technologies on Bitcoin's scarcity. For instance, advancements in quantum computing could potentially break Bitcoin's cryptography, rendering the S2F model's assumptions about scarcity obsolete.
In sum, the Stock-to-Flow (S2F) model is a popular framework used to price Bitcoin, but it has several limitations and criticisms. The model's simplicity, reliance on historical data, self-fulfilling prophecy, and failure to account for disruptive technologies are some of the major criticisms raised by experts and market participants.
Sources:
"The Bitcoin Stock-to-Flow Model Is Fundamentally Flawed." Nic Carter, CoinDesk, 17 Nov. 2020, https://www.coindesk.com/the-bitcoin-stock-to-flow-model-is-fundamentally-flawed.
"Critiques of the Stock to Flow Model." Hasu and Qiao Wang, Uncommon Core, 17 Nov. 2020, https://unchained-capital.com/critiques-of-the-stock-to-flow-model/.
"Why the Bitcoin Stock-to-Flow Model Is Wrong." Willy Woo, Medium, 16 Nov. 2020, https://medium.com/@woonomic/why-the-bitcoin-stock-to-flow-model-is-wrong-365cfb33f989.
Bitcoin's price exhibits a power law relationship, which can be observed in its distribution of price changes. This means that Bitcoin has a "fat tail" distribution, where extreme events (such as price increases or decreases of a large magnitude) are more common than they would be in a normal distribution.
First, let's consider the potential of Bitcoin's market. One expert, Tim Draper, a well-known venture capitalist, boldly predicted that Bitcoin would reach $250,000 by 2022. That's a staggering increase from its current value of around $50,000 as of February 2021. Draper is known for his successful investments in companies like Tesla, Skype, and Hotmail, lending credence to his prediction.
But what drives this growth? Consider the limited supply of Bitcoin, capped at 21 million coins, and increasing demand as more people and institutions adopt it as a form of payment and store of value. This dynamic alone could drive the price upward.
Now, let's turn to regulations. Regulatory bodies around the world are taking notice of Bitcoin's rising popularity and are working to establish clear guidelines. For instance, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has approved a Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF), which allows investors to buy into Bitcoin without directly owning it. This move could open the door for more institutional investors to enter the market, further driving up demand and price.
But regulations can also have a chilling effect. China, for example, has taken a hardline stance against cryptocurrencies, banning initial coin offerings (ICOs) and shutting down domestic Bitcoin exchanges. This has led to a decrease in Bitcoin trading volume in the country.
However, it's not all doom and gloom. Some countries, like Switzerland and Malta, are embracing Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, establishing clear regulations and even creating "Crypto Valleys" to attract blockchain companies.
In conclusion, the future of Bitcoin's market and regulations is a mixed bag. On one hand, we have the potential for massive growth driven by increasing demand and limited supply. On the other, we have the threat of regulatory crackdowns that could stifle this growth. But one thing is clear: Bitcoin is here to stay, and its impact on the financial world will only continue to grow.
Here's a hand-drawn plot that illustrates the potential growth of Bitcoin's price:
250,000
^
|
| .
| .
| .
|_______________________>
0 5 10 Year
Join Roshni on Peerlist!
Join amazing folks like Roshni and thousands of other people in tech.
Create ProfileJoin with Roshni’s personal invite link.
0
4
0